Should You Refinance Your Mortgage?

August 24, 2020

On March 15, The Federal Reserve dropped the federal funds rate to 0-0.25%, which then sent average mortgage rates to 50-year lows, with an average 30-year mortgage around 3% (Source: FreddieMac.com).


So what does this mean for someone with a mortgage? When does it make sense to refinance?


There are two rules of thumb that I like to start with:

  1. Can you drop your interest rate by 1%-2%?
  2. Can you pay off your closing costs within a year or two? (Average closing costs range from 2% to 4% of the loan.)


For example, let us take a $200,000 30-year mortgage at 5% with a monthly payment of $1,074 (before taxes and insurance). If refinanced at 3%, we have an $843 monthly payment, or $231/month savings. And with closing costs of $4,000 (2% of the loan), it takes 17 months to break even ($4,000/$231). This is compelling. Not only does it drop the payment, but it only takes 17 months to break even on closing costs.


GET THE LATEST UPDATES: Download the free Tennessean app on your mobile device


As a note, while it may technically make sense on paper to refinance even if a break even is not reached within the first year or two, it can be difficult to predict the long term. For example, your job may change next year and you may decide to sell your house. This is why I usually encourage folks to refinance if they can break even in the short term.


There are many other things you may want to consider when refinancing, such as changing from a variable rate to fixed rate, locking in a shorter term, or changing the amount of the loan.


Every situation is different, so consider reaching out to a mortgage broker or financial adviser to see what makes sense for you.


Hunter Yarbrough, CPA, CFP, is an executive vice president and financial adviser with CapWealth. He is passionate about taking a holistic view of personal finance, including investments, taxes, retirement, education, estate planning, and insurance. For more information about Hunter and CapWealth, visit capwealthgroup.com.


People looking at documents in an office with large windows. The Kiplinger logo is in the top left corner.
By Jennifer Pagliara Horton September 9, 2025
CapWealth’s Jennifer Pagliara Horton outlines six key items to consider before retiring, including questions on health, longevity, and lifestyle planning.
Documents related to estate planning: a trust, will, notebook with common oversight topics, and a property record book.
By Jennifer Pagliara Horton September 9, 2025
Overlooking key details in your estate plan can create stress for loved ones. Avoid common estate plan misses and protect your family’s future.
Estate planning documents: Will, notebook, family photo, pencil, and book labeled
By Jennifer Horton Pagliara August 26, 2025
Don’t let estate planning myths put your family at risk. Discover the truth behind common misconceptions and protect what matters most.
By Hillary Stalker August 12, 2025
Reset your family’s finances for the school year with smart budgeting tips while staying focused on long-term goals like savings and portfolio management.
Smiling man in a suit jacket, mountains in the background,
By Gregory FCA August 1, 2025
PlanAdviser reports Dean Shahan has joined CapWealth as EVP and financial advisor, bringing fresh perspective and elevating client service.
A black and white cartoon showing financial planning for every decade of life
By Hillary Stalker July 29, 2025
Five key financial planning tips for your 20s, 30s, 40s, and beyond. Learn how to build and grow wealth, prepare for retirement, and protect your future.
Logo of
By CapWealth July 25, 2025
InvestmentNews covers CapWealth’s addition of Dean Shahan as executive vice president and financial advisor, strengthening the firm’s advisory team.
Dean Shahan wears a gray blazer and a light blue shirt, with a mountainous background.
By CapWealth July 24, 2025
CapWealth welcomes Dean Shahan as EVP and financial advisor, expanding expertise in planning, strategy, and client-focused wealth management.
Nashville Post logo.
By CapWealth July 24, 2025
Nashville Post highlights Blake Harrison joining CapWealth as EVP of Wealth Management in their “People on the Move” section.
Show More

Share Article